CryptoPotato
CryptoPotato
  • Crypto News
  • Margin Trading
  • Guides
    • Bitcoin & Crypto Guides 101
    • Bitcoin For Beginners
    • Editorials
  • DeFi & NFT
  • Buy
  • Language
    • Spanish
    • Turkish
    • German
    • Bulgarian
  • Crypto News
  • Bitcoin For Beginners
  • Cryptocurrency Guides 101
  • Editorials
  • Bitcoin & Crypto Margin Trading
  • DeFi & NFT News
  • Bitcoin Price Analysis
  • Ethereum (ETH) Price Analysis
  • Ripple (XRP) Price Analysis
  • Market Updates
  • Interviews
  • Buy Bitcoin with Card
  • CryptoPotato Spanish
  • CryptoPotato Turkey
  • CryptoPotato Germany
  • CryptoPotato Bulgaria
  • Market Updates
  • BTC Analysis
  • ETH Analysis
  • XRP Analysis
  • Interviews
CryptoPotato
CryptoPotato
  • Crypto News
  • Margin Trading
  • Guides
    • Bitcoin & Crypto Guides 101
    • Bitcoin For Beginners
    • Editorials
  • DeFi & NFT
  • Buy
  • Language
    • Spanish
    • Turkish
    • German
    • Bulgarian
  • Crypto News
  • Bitcoin For Beginners
  • Cryptocurrency Guides 101
  • Editorials
  • Bitcoin & Crypto Margin Trading
  • DeFi & NFT News
  • Bitcoin Price Analysis
  • Ethereum (ETH) Price Analysis
  • Ripple (XRP) Price Analysis
  • Market Updates
  • Interviews
  • Buy Bitcoin with Card
  • CryptoPotato Spanish
  • CryptoPotato Turkey
  • CryptoPotato Germany
  • CryptoPotato Bulgaria
Home » Crypto News » Will Your Bitcoin Investments Count When You File for Bankruptcy?

Will Your Bitcoin Investments Count When You File for Bankruptcy?

Author: Summer Hirst

Last Updated Aug 26, 2019 @ 12:29
Getting your audio player ready...

TL;DR

  • Bitcoin can be considered as a commodity or a currency, and the law is split over the definition.
  • This can make things difficult, especially in bankruptcy cases.
  • Different rulings have created a divide, and it’s essential for bankruptcy experts to understand Bitcoin and to arrive at a consensus.

When a person or firm files for bankruptcy, what should happen to their Bitcoin investments is becoming a cause of concern for legal authorities.

The struggle to find a solution to crypto related insolvency cases has become difficult since there is no consensus over what Bitcoin exactly is – whether it’s a commodity or a currency, or something else.

It will take time for legislative bodies to decide the right categorization for Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. But courts don’t have that time, especially when it comes to resolving real disputes like bankruptcy.

Bitcoin Identity Crisis

The categorization of Bitcoin as a currency/commodity can have a significant impact on bankruptcy cases.

Bitcoin as a currency

Bitcoin can be used to pay for goods and services, which is why it can be considered a currency. It is accepted all over the world and offers merchants low transaction costs, fast transaction speeds, and safety.

However, it is not endorsed by any country as their currency. This is why it can be considered as an article for barter and not really a legal tender.

Bitcoin as a commodity

Bitcoin can be compared to gold as an asset. For example, both have a particular element of scarcity as there is a finite supply of both. Bitcoin can go up to a maximum of 21 million. Gold and Bitcoin have a finite value, which makes them assets instead of currencies.

How a court perceives, Bitcoin can affect a bankruptcy case, and thus it’s important to define what Bitcoin really is.

bankruptcy
Bankruptcy

Court’s Opinion on Bitcoin

The Case OF CLI Holdings 33 and HashFast Technologies

When it comes to bankruptcy that involves cryptocurrencies, two prominent cases come to mind – CLI Holdings and HashFast Technologies.

Each of these cases pondered on the crypto classification issue, but no definitive decision could be taken. This is why it is still uncertain of how crypto should be treated in any future proceedings related to insolvency cases.

In the CLI Holdings case, a Bitcoin miner borrowed $75,000 for mining equipment. He was supposed to repay the amount using the first 7,984 Bitcoin he mined.

Since the value of Bitcoin shot up, this value became millions of dollars, making the loan repayment an impossible task. The miner discontinued the payments and filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. In this case, the court upheld the contract as they seemed to treat the Bitcoin as a commodity.

In the second case, HashFast Technologies transferred 3,000 Bitcoin to another party before filing for bankruptcy. At the moment of transfer, those Bitcoin were worth $363,861.43. When the court proceedings began, the value of those Bitcoins reached $1.3 million. The trustee maintained that Bitcoin is a commodity and should hence be returned to the bankruptcy estate.

The ruling was made partially in favor of the trustee. However, the judgment did not include whether the court considered Bitcoin as a commodity or a currency.

An important point to note here is that the IRS considers Bitcoin to be an intangible asset, which means it can be linked to capital gains/losses.

The Other Side of the (Bit) Coin

Other government agencies and courts have chosen the other side of the divide. For instance, the US District Court for East Texas ruled that Bitcoin is a currency and should be treated as a form of money.

Many merchants have started accepting crypto as a payment method, which makes it closer to a currency than a commodity.

Why Bankruptcy Experts Must Understand Cryptocurrencies

While Bitcoin stays in a divide, over 100,000 BTC transactions take place daily. While many people think Bitcoin is synonymous with cryptocurrencies, there are over 900 cryptocurrencies that exist today.

Many businesses such as Expedia, Subway, PayPal, Shopify, and Microsoft accept Bitcoin as a payment method. As the mainstream use of Bitcoin increases, it will soon be considered an asset of the debtor in cases such as those related to bankruptcy.

This is especially true for companies that stockpile Bitcoin. If a company with many Bitcoin files for insolvency, the crypto assets will need to be evaluated for the bankruptcy case.

Since several companies are widely accepting Bitcoin, it becomes even more important for legal and financial experts to understand the nature of this asset and how a court should treat it for bankruptcy cases.

Conclusion

While the general public might consider cryptocurrencies as currencies, some judgments favor the notion that crypto is inherently a commodity. It is unclear how the classification will be done, but since cryptocurrencies are gaining momentum, the courts will need to settle how these digital assets should be sorted.

Since the technological innovation in this field has outpaced the legal system, the regulatory response is incomplete and fragmented. The US Code needs to be adequately amended to provide guidance on this matter because different classifications will make the divide even wider as different cases give different judgments, classifying crypto in different ways.

SPECIAL OFFER (Sponsored)
Binance Free $600 (CryptoPotato Exclusive): Use this link to register a new account and receive $600 exclusive welcome offer on Binance (full details).

LIMITED OFFER for CryptoPotato readers at Bybit: Use this link to register and open a $500 FREE position on any coin!

Enjoy reading? Share with your friends
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Telegram

About The Author

Summer Hirst
More posts by this author

Summer is an advocate of free speech and privacy. She is a cybersecurity expert and her current focus is on cryptocurrency and blockchain technology. As a content creator, she aspires to excel in the field of digital security. When not writing, she enjoys gardening and reading. Contact Summer: Facebook

Join Our Community

FacebookX YouTubeTelegram


Editorials
10 Best Meme Coins to Watch in June 2025

10 Best Meme Coins to Watch in June 2025

7 Best Meme Coin Presales to Watch in June 2025

7 Best Meme Coin Presales to Watch in June 2025

Toobit Review 2025: Is Toobit a Safe Crypto Exchange?

Toobit Review 2025: Is Toobit a Safe Crypto Exchange?

Hyperliquid Bridge: How to Bridge USDC to Hyperliquid

Hyperliquid Bridge: How to Bridge USDC to Hyperliquid

11 Best Crypto Presales to Consider in June 2025

11 Best Crypto Presales to Consider in June 2025

Need for Speed – Only Ultra-Fast Blockchains Will Win the Adoption Race (Opinion)

Need for Speed – Only Ultra-Fast Blockchains Will Win the Adoption Race (Opinion)

The 5 Best Bitcoin Mining Pools in 2025: Complete Guide

The 5 Best Bitcoin Mining Pools in 2025: Complete Guide

Join Our Newsletter
Become a CryptoPotato VIP
One Weekly Email Can Change Your Crypto Life.
Sign-up FREE to receive our extended weekly market update and coin analysis report
We NEVER send spam. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Invalid email address
Thanks for subscribing!
Footer Logo
About
Advertise on CryptoPotato
About Us | Contact Us | Careers
Editorial Policy
Terms of service | Privacy Policy | GDPR
More Sections
IEO List | Evaluations
Airdrops
Scholarship
Disclaimer
Disclaimer: Information found on CryptoPotato is those of writers quoted. It does not represent the opinions of CryptoPotato on whether to buy, sell, or hold any investments. You are advised to conduct your own research before making any investment decisions. Use provided information at your own risk. Full disclaimer
© Copyright CryptoPotato 2016 - 2025
Scroll to top
One Daily Email Can Change Your Crypto Life.

Sign-up FREE to receive our extended daily market update and coin analysis report

We never send SPAM. You can unsubscribe at any moment
Invalid email address
Thanks for subscribing!